Teaching powerful problem solving in math: A collaborative approach through lesson study

What does the research say?

The research shows that implementing schoolwide lesson study alongside Teaching Through Problem-solving (TTP) leads to dramatic, equitable gains in student mathematics achievement. Across urban public elementary and K–8 schools serving predominantly low-income and historically marginalized communities, students engaged in TTP performed far above district norms on rigorous standardized assessments like the California Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBAC) across all demographic subgroups. Instruction in these schools shifted away from procedural memorization toward student-centered inquiry, where students construct mathematical concepts by tackling novel problems and engaging in core routines such as reflective journals, organized board work, and student-led discussions. Additionally, the findings demonstrate that transforming adult professional learning through collegial, teacher-led lesson study enhances teacher collaboration, strengthens collective efficacy, and significantly reduces teacher turnover.

Why is it important?

This research is critical because traditional mathematics instruction in the U.S. continues to perpetuate widespread educational inequity and stagnant achievement. Memorization-focused teaching disproportionately impacts low-income communities, leaving many high school graduates unprepared for higher education and technical careers. Furthermore, national (NAEP) and international (PISA) assessment scores have remained flat or below average for decades, demonstrating that traditional “quick fixes” and one-shot professional development workshops fail to produce lasting systemic change. TTP and schoolwide lesson study offer a grounded, sustainable alternative that builds deep conceptual understanding, fosters mathematical reasoning, and empowers students as confident, joyful problem-solvers. The importance of lesson study as a means to foster deeper learning only grows in importance as AI-enabled technologies threaten deeper learning processes.

What are the implications for improvement efforts?

For school and district improvement efforts, the primary implication is that instructional transformation requires investing in teacher-led systems of professional learning rather than relying on top-down mandates. Sustainable reform depends on nurturing key local conditions, including intrinsic teacher motivation, integrated teacher-administrator leadership, and a shared schoolwide vision for student success. District leadership must actively support these initiatives by providing time, schedule flexibility, and policy waivers (such as using specialized curricula or replacing standard evaluations with lesson study participation). Ultimately, improvement frameworks must allow for organic, teacher-supported expansion (“slow is okay”), honoring teacher voice and utilizing “street-level” observational data to continuously refine classroom practice. The promise of this book is that it showcases that Lesson study is not only a valid improvement method for individual classrooms but can successfully be implemented at the school and district level.

Read the book

Nothing quite replaces reading the original from which this chapter was sampled: Teaching Powerful Problem-Solving in Math: A Collaborative Approach Through Lesson Study